Product Hunt First Comment: Template and Examples
Divv Saxena
Founder & Flight Director •

On this page
Quick answer
The first comment on a Product Hunt launch is the Maker comment. You write it in the launch editor, it posts with your launch and stays pinned at the top. Cover who you are, why you built it, what it does, who it is for, what is different, and one specific question.
The first comment on a Product Hunt launch is the Maker comment. You write it before launch day in the First comment box of the launch editor, it is posted when your launch goes live, and it stays pinned at the top of the discussion. Product Hunt's help center calls it "one of the most-read parts of your page" (checked 17 Nov 2026).
Product Hunt also says what belongs in it: who you are, why you built it, what it does, who it's for, what makes it different, what feedback you want, and any offer. This page turns that list into a template you can fill in, shows three examples, and covers the one rule that gets launches removed.
Where the first comment lives
These details come from Product Hunt's launch guide article Build your product page (checked 17 Nov 2026):
- You write it in the First comment box inside the launch editor, not on launch day.
- It is posted and pinned when the launch goes live, so you don't have to be awake at 12:01 AM Pacific Time to post it.
- The limit is 5,000 characters.
- You can use bold, lists, links, quotes and @mentions to tag your co-makers.
- It is optional. The editor lists it under "Make it stand out", next to extra images, a video and pricing, not under the required items.
- Once the launch is live, your co-makers can join in by replying to comments.
The seven parts Product Hunt asks for
Product Hunt's list, with what each part is for:
- 1Who you are. One line about you and your team. People want to know a person is behind the page.
- 2Why you built it. The problem you ran into yourself. This is the part readers remember.
- 3What it does. Two or three things, in plain words. Not the full feature list.
- 4Who it's for. Name the people. "Freelance designers who invoice by hand" is better than "everyone".
- 5What makes it different. Your edge over what people use today.
- 6What you want to hear. One specific question, so people know what to reply with.
- 7Any offer. If you set up a Product Hunt promo code, mention it here.
Product Hunt's advice on tone is short: "Write like a person, not a press release." A few emojis as bullets are fine. Images and GIFs are welcome.

Product Hunt first comment template
Copy this, replace the brackets, then delete any line that doesn't apply to you.
Hi Product Hunt! I'm [name], [one line: what you do / who is on the team].
[The problem, as it happened to you. One or two sentences.]
So we built [product]: [what it does in one plain sentence].
What it does today:
- [Thing 1]
- [Thing 2]
- [Thing 3]
It's for [the specific people you built it for].
[One sentence on how it differs from what they use now.]
[Offer, if you have one: what it is and the promo code.]
I'd love your take on one thing: [a specific question].
I'm here all day and will reply to every comment.Three examples
The products below are made up, so you can see the structure without borrowing someone else's story. Don't copy the wording. Copy the order.
A solo maker with a small tool
Hi Product Hunt! I'm Ana, a freelance developer. I built Hourfinch on evenings and weekends.
Every month I lost an hour copying time entries from my tracker into invoices, and twice I billed the wrong client.
Hourfinch reads your time tracker and drafts the invoice for you.
What it does today:
- Imports hours from Toggl and Harvest
- Groups them by client and project
- Exports a PDF you can send as is
It's for freelancers who bill by the hour and don't want a full accounting suite. It does one job and has no setup beyond connecting your tracker.
One thing I'd love to know: which tracker should I support next?
I'm here all day and will answer every comment.A small team with an offer
Hi everyone! I'm Sam, and with @maya and @leo I make Sortkettle.
We ran support for a 12-person startup and kept answering the same five questions while real bugs waited in the same inbox.
Sortkettle sorts incoming support email into "answer exists" and "needs a human" before anyone opens it.
- Suggests the saved reply when one fits
- Flags messages that mention billing or data loss
- Works inside the inbox you already use
It's for teams of 2 to 20 where support is everyone's side job. Bigger helpdesks do more. We tried to do less, faster.
We added an offer for the Product Hunt community to this launch: 3 months free.
What would stop you from trying this on your real inbox? That is the feedback we need most.A relaunch after a major update
Hi Product Hunt! I'm Priya, maker of Trailjot. We launched here last year, and your comments shaped this version.
The most common request was offline mode. The second was "please make search faster". Both are in version 2.
What's new:
- Works fully offline and syncs when you reconnect
- Search returns results as you type
- A new import for Markdown folders
Trailjot is still for researchers who take notes in the field, away from good wifi.
If you tried version 1 and left, what made you leave? I'd like to know if we fixed it.That last example follows Product Hunt's own advice for a second launch: "tell the community how their feedback shaped the product."
The one rule: ask for feedback, never for upvotes
Product Hunt is direct about this: "Ask for feedback, never for upvotes." Its example of a good ask is "What would make this useful for your team?" Its example of a line that breaks the rules is "Please upvote!" (checked 17 Nov 2026).
The same guide says asking for upvotes "can get your launch removed". So keep the word out of your first comment, and out of the emails and posts that point to it.
Lines to cut, and what to write instead
- "We're thrilled to announce..." Start with your name and the problem.
- A list of twelve features. Pick the two or three a new user meets in the first five minutes.
- "Any feedback is welcome!" Ask one question a stranger can answer in a sentence.
- "The best / #1 / revolutionary..." Say what it does. Product Hunt gives the same advice for taglines: skip hype like "the best" or "#1".
- Your company history. One line on who you are is enough. The story people want is the problem.
After it's posted
The first comment starts the thread. What you do next keeps it going. Product Hunt's guidance for launch day is to answer every comment you can, as close to real time as possible, and to split the day with your team so someone is always online. People also keep finding a launch for days afterwards, so check back after launch day too.
The same note is useful outside Product Hunt. Most places you launch have a spot for the story behind the product, so keep it in the doc where you store your tagline and screenshots. Our product launch checklist has it as step 18, and how to launch a product covers where Product Hunt fits in a four-week plan.
If you are still preparing the page itself, see Product Hunt gallery image size and launch specs and how to get featured on Product Hunt.
When the comment and the page are ready, you can also launch your product on DivvLaunches. A free listing includes a nofollow link. A First Class listing is $9.99 (checked 17 Nov 2026) and the link is marked rel=sponsored.
FAQ
How long should a Product Hunt first comment be?
Product Hunt sets a maximum of 5,000 characters and no minimum. The examples above are about 100 to 125 words each, which is enough to cover all seven parts. That length is my suggestion, not a Product Hunt rule.
Do I have to post the first comment at 12:01 AM Pacific Time?
No. You write it in the launch editor before you schedule, and it is posted and pinned automatically when the launch goes live.
Is the first comment required?
No. Name, tagline, description, logo, a gallery image, launch tags and your role are required. The first comment is on the editor's "Make it stand out" list.
Who should write it, the hunter or the maker?
The maker. Product Hunt defines the Maker comment as "the first comment on a launch, written by the maker", and recommends that makers post their own product.
Can I ask people to upvote in the first comment?
No. Product Hunt's rules say to ask for feedback, comments and help spreading the word, never for upvotes.

Divv Saxena
PILOT IN CHIEFFounder & Flight Director
Guiding indie hackers and startup founders through takeoff, daily community upvoting, and verified directory distribution on DivvLaunches.
Ready to launch your product to early adopters?
Join the daily flight schedule on DivvLaunches. Up to 10 free launches take off each day at 00:00 IST (India time), with live upvoting until midnight and a permanent podium for the top 3.
CONTROL TOWER RADAR
More Dispatches from Flight School
Pre-flight manuals, launch day blueprints, and founder growth telemetry.

How to Launch on Product Hunt in 2026 (and Where to Launch Next)
How to launch on Product Hunt in 2026: the current rules (no Launch Now, a one-week account wait, 30-day scheduling), the steps, a check of its link markup, and where to launch next.

Best Time to Launch on Product Hunt (by Time Zone)
You don't pick a time on Product Hunt. Every launch goes live at 12:01 AM Pacific Time on the date you schedule and runs until midnight Pacific. What you pick is the day, and Product Hunt says no weekday guarantees a top spot. Choose the day you can be online for.